Skip to content
Bombay High Court

Vipul D. Shah vs Dinesh D. Shah

COMMERCIAL FIRST APPEAL (ST) 24138 of 2022 · 04 November 2026

Judgments / Bombay High Court

Case details

Court
Bombay High Court
Case number
COMMERCIAL FIRST APPEAL (ST) 24138 of 2022
Date
04 November 2026
Judges
G. S. KULKARNI, DR. NEELA GOKHALE
Case type
Civil
Result
disposed of

Headnote

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) -- Service of summons -- Ex-parte decree -- Validity of service -- The Appellant and Respondent were traders; the Respondent advanced a loan to the Appellant, and the Appellant stopped paying interest -- The Respondent filed a suit and served the summons at an under-construction site, claiming the Appellant did not receive it -- The Trial Court passed an ex-parte decree based on the Respondent’s affidavit of service. -- The High Court held that the service was not valid as the Respondent deliberately chose an incorrect address, and the Trial Court failed to verify the service properly -- The Court emphasized that service must be valid and that the Respondent must prove the service was properly done. -- The ex-parte decree is quashed, and the suit is restored for trial on its merits

Read the full judgment

The complete text, citations, AI summary and original PDF are available inside Judisyn.