Skip to content
Karnataka High Court

Skanda Sai Marketing vs Kondandappa

Regular First Appeal 367 of 2020 (MON) · 05 November 2026

Judgments / Karnataka High Court

Case details

Court
Karnataka High Court
Case number
Regular First Appeal 367 of 2020 (MON)
Date
05 November 2026
Judges
Rajesh Rai K
Result
Partly Allowed

Headnote

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 -- Counter-claim, Court fee, Running account -- The plaintiff filed a suit to recover Rs.2,58,156/- from the defendant, claiming an outstanding balance based on invoices and a running account -- The Trial Court dismissed the suit but also granted an unpleaded claim to the defendant for refund of Rs.4,41,844/- without a formal counter-claim, court fee, or framed issues -- The High Court held that the Trial Court erred in granting the defendant's unpleaded claim as it violated procedural requirements under Order VIII Rule 6-A of the C.P.C. -- The High Court set aside the part of the judgment directing the refund of the excess amount -- The Trial Court's decision to grant the unpleaded claim was legally unsustainable and contrary to the canons of civil procedure -- The appeal was allowed in part, and the refund direction was set aside

Read the full judgment

The complete text, citations, AI summary and original PDF are available inside Judisyn.