Skip to content
Privy Council

Municipality Of Hyderabad vs Mangharam Hukumatrai

Privy Co 28 of 1947 · 06 December 1949

Judgments / Privy Council

Case details

Court
Privy Council
Case number
Privy Co 28 of 1947
Date
06 December 1949
Judges
Lord Simonds, Macdermott, Radcliffe, John Beaumont, Lionel Leach
Result
Appeal allowed

Opening of the judgment

1. This is an ex parte appeal from a decree of the Chief Court of Sind dated 26th May 1942, which reversed a judgment of the first class Subordinate Judge, Hyderabad, dated 8th October 1938. The dispute to which the appeal relates arises out of a contract which the parties entered into on 15th February 1934, and the interpretation of that contract is the central issue of the case. There was a marked divergence between their respective submissions as to the construction of the contract, and a divergence not less marked in the evidence that they tendered on certain important issues of fact. The trial Judge interpreted the contract in a sense favourable to the appellant's contention, while the…

Read the full judgment

The complete text, citations, AI summary and original PDF are available inside Judisyn.